To: David Scott
From: Jim Buckley
Thanks. Your Milner is what we call a Rosin in the US. My evaluation, as I say at http://www.rumford.com/tech16.html is:
[The Rosin fireplace is] a modification of a Rumford by a man named Rosin who developed the modification in the 1930's. Rosins are good fireplaces but I'm not convinced they are better than Rumfords. Rosin, himself, was very modest in his proposal which was based on scale modeling and so subject to errors of scale. He also didn't use heat. His models involved dropping salts in a fluid through a small scale model fireplace and observing the "streamlines" by taking time exposure photographs of the salts falling through the fluid. Trying to maximize radiation, Rosin suggested a parabolic shaped "modern" firebox shape rather than one made of firebrick and to minimize turbulence he recommended streamlining the exit to the throat as well as the entrance as Rumford did.
So, is it better? I don't know since none of the Rosins - Belfires in New York or Frisch Rosin in Washington - have been built as Rosin suggested and, in any configuration, have not been tested (or if they have the results have not been made public) for emissions or efficiency as an open fireplace. I believe Belfires has an "optional" stainless steel Rumford throat modeled after our Rumford throat but not the hour glass shaped throat Rosin advocated. The claims for improved aerodynamics or cleaner-burning are all sales propaganda in the absence of third party test data.
Rosin's original essay, "The Aerodynamics of Domestic Open Fireplaces" was published in England in the Journal of the Institute of Fuel, Vol 12, 1939, pp. 198-224.
I've scanned in some images of Milner firebacks from product catalogues,
and I've attached a pdf with fitting instructions.
The following are manufacturers' websites:
Hope this helps to describe the "Milner". I wonder if it was developed
from the Rumford? Information doesn't seem to be too readily available.
I don't know if it would work with logs stacked on end.
I'll send pictures of the fireplace opening in due course.
[Back to Technical Discussion]
Buckley Rumford Fireplace Home Page
Copyright 1996 - 2006 Jim Buckley
All rights reserved.